I have had extensive experience with extended maintenance contracts. They are very expensive and provide the deception to the consumer that they cover virtually every repair that their client may encounter while owning the vehicle and through the term of the contract. These statements cannot be further from the truth. There are even different levels of these contracts that cover different areas of the vehicle and deceptive sales practices by the issuing dealer (which makes a substantial commission for selling these contracts by the way) fool the naive consumer into thinking they will be fully covered for any repair to the vehicle. This oftens leaves the repair shop looking like the bad guy when they cannot talk the representative from the maintenance contract office into covering a repair on their vehicle or receiving 100% of the repair (minus the deductible – which has varying levels as well – normally depending on how much you spent for the contract).
The repair shop, trying in earnest to please it’s customer will normally always try to deal with these organizations to obtain coverage for a repair. Oftentimes it depends on how the service facility rep uses their words as to how much of the repair they can achieve coverage for. Use the wrong technical term and the conversation is ended with no coverage and a flag goes in the file which normally means that is the last word and any rebuttal against the decision appears to make the repair facility appear deceptive in pursuing coverage.
Oftentimes they will cover a repair performed by their methods only and any diversity exhibited by the repair facility will warrant a non coverage. This places the maintenance contract facility in total control of the repair. For instance in our shop a often failed apparatus on a motorhome is an autopark system which automatically applies the park brake when park is selected on the transmission gear selector. Usually the failure is a leakage of the actuator switch which is a seperately available part from General Motors and costs about $30.00 but the maintenance contract people will only cover the autopark assembly which includes the actuator switch which costs $800.00.
On electrical repairs they normally only cover 1 hour of labor which does not cover the diagnosis of most electrical repairs. They exclude many items from coverage. They exclude many miscellaneous charges that most shops charge. They exclude freon from air conditioning repairs. They exclude transmission fluid from automatic transmission repairs. They claim that these limitations and exclusions are written in the contract but the terminology is very complicated and not easily understood by the average consumer. The salesman is no help because he wants you to buy the contract. If he completely explained the contract – who in their right mind would buy it!
From our experience if they cover the repair at all the coverage is usually limited to 50% to 70% of the total bill. The customer always ends up owing the balance. I looked at a contract the other day and the family had paid $5900.00 for the contract on a $136,000.00 motorhome. If you ever do end up recovering near the full paid amount you can best believe that you would have spent at least that much more in non covered and excluded repairs. You would be better off placing the monthly fees you are paying in addition to the payment (which most folks finance this contract amount by the way) into a savings account which draws interest and only use it for maintenance to your vehicle.
If there are any sales reps or maintenace contract reps out there that disagree with this blog I welcome their feedback. We have dealt with virtually every organization that carries these contracts and have not found a consumer friendly one yet. Visit www.trucktechautoandrv.com for more information on this subject.